
Detaining captives without trial, as the US is doing at Guantánamo Bay, Cuba, results in continuing, bitter, international criticism. Yet trying them is fraught with difficulty, as lengthy proceedings against admitted Al Qaeda member Zacarias Moussaoui have shown.
The administration's defenders say that dealing with an amorphous foe demands an ill-defined detention policy, and that there aren't any serious alternatives. Critics say that may not be the case - and that the issue is blackening the nation's name overseas.
"In a general way, the world just sees the US as this powerful entity intent on stepping on other people's rights for the sake of its own security," says Thomas Carothers, director of the democracy and rule of law project at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.
Last weekend, reports in the British press indicated that US officials have asked the British government for advice concerning methods of closing the Guantánamo camp and repatriating its detainees.
London has launched controversial attempts to return terror suspects to home countries in North Africa and the Middle East. Lebanon, Jordan, and Libya have signed pacts promising that they will not abuse these returnees.
Publicly, US officials say that there are no immediate plans to close the Guantánamo installation, but that the US obviously will continue to weigh what to do with its approximately 500 inmates, for the long term.
"Hopefully, over the years, we will find a way to either release them to their country of origin or they will declare that they no longer want to kill us," Deputy Assistant Secretary of State Colleen Graffy said in a broadcast interview on Sunday.
In recent months the Guantánamo prison has attracted an increasing amount of international attention - unwelcome attention, in the White House's view.
Release of voluminous data about the detainees to the Associated Press, per a Freedom of Information Act request, has made some Guantánamo detainees seem like hapless victims - though others indeed have come across as committed terrorists. And a UN Commission on Human Rights report issued last month alleged that torture occurs at Guantánamo, and said that the camp should be closed without delay.
However, UN officials involved in this report never actually visited Guantánamo, notes Nile Gardiner, a security policy fellow at the Heritage Foundation.
Guantánamo's long-term future should be decided by US security needs, says Gardiner.
"At present there are no serious alternatives being proposed," he says. "It remains the best option in a highly complex global war."
Meanwhile, the sentencing trial of Mr. Zacarias Moussaoui, the only man charged in the US in connection with the Sept. 11 attacks, remained on hold as of publication time.
US District Judge Leonie M. Brinkema halted the trial on Monday, and threatened to remove the death penalty as a possible sentence, following the disclosure that a government lawyer had improperly shared testimony with witnesses.
Moussaoui has admitted being a member of Al Qaeda, and being a part of a conspiracy aimed at flying airplanes into US buildings. But he has said his role was to be in a follow-on attack, and that he had no part in Sept. 11.
His legal proceedings have dragged on for years, in part due to his own behavior. Analysts said the latest glitch seemed an inexcusable error on the part of the government lawyer, veteran Federal Aviation Administration attorney Carla Martin.

A Free practice account is a great way to experience the Forex market without risking any money.
For Novice Traders
For those who did not trade in the forex market before can get accustomed to following a market, and open themselves to a whole new way to invest, and it also gives them the chance to understand how the trading platform works.
For Regular Traders
For those who are familliar with trading in forex market, a practice account can help them to get use to the particular characteristics of the Forex market or our trading platform.
For Experienced and Professional Traders
A practice account can even help experienced and professional traders as they can test and practice their trading strategies without risking capital.
Generally the Demo Account has the same capabilities of the real account, the only difference between them is that the real account is with real money and the practice account is with virtual money.
Open Now A Free $ 500'000 Account With Sigma Forex and discover a whole new way to invest.
Sigma Account allow you to open Micro, Mini and Standard lot through only one account and trade in Forex Market
In order to register for a practice account, please Download Sigma Forex Platform and open new account as illustrated below and you will have unlimited access to our Platform for the next 30-days.
If you have any problem regarding Sigma Practice Account you can see User Guides or click on the Live Chat button on the right menu and our customer support staff will help you through the process.
No comments:
Post a Comment